FAQ

The questions consumer-brand operators actually ask. Answered.

Everything we keep off the main pages for the sake of brevity lives here — how the assessment works, how we're paid, and the category detail. Email us if your question isn't here.

01The Basics

The short version, in plain English. The deeper detail is all below.

What does Ad Astra actually do?

We're an independent business assessment. We evaluate the operational areas most teams never have time to review — HR, IT, employee benefits, supply chain, automation, and operations — identify where you're overpaying or exposed, and connect you with vetted providers when there's something worth fixing. Evaluate, identify, connect. That's the whole idea.

Is this like a business health check?

Exactly like one — think of it as an annual physical for your operation. We look across the categories that quietly drift — subscriptions that auto-renew, contracts that roll over, vendors whose terms changed — and tell you where money is leaking. Most operators are too busy running the business to track all of it. That's the gap we fill.

Can I start with one area, or do I have to do everything?

One area, a few, or the whole business — entirely your call. Start with a single challenge, like your software spend or your PEO, or run a full review across categories. We meet you where you are.

Do I have to act on what you find?

No. The assessment hands you the opportunities in plain numbers; you decide what, if anything, to do about them. Implement one recommendation, several, or none. No obligation, no pressure.

Are you a consultant we keep on retainer?

No. We're not a permanent layer above your business, and there's no retainer to get started. The assessment is the product; help with implementation is optional, and only happens if you want it. You can engage us for a single issue and be done — or come back when something else comes up.

What does it cost to get started?

Nothing. Discovery and the assessment are free. When you choose to act on a recommendation, the provider you go with funds our fee — disclosed on the contract before you sign. If there's nothing worth doing, you owe nothing.

Why does Ad Astra exist?

Because no operator can stay expert across every category at once. The pace of change has outrun even good teams — subscriptions auto-renew, vendors change terms, compliance keeps moving — faster than anyone running the actual business can track. We watch that big picture so your people don't have to.

02Engagement & Pricing

How we get paid, what discovery looks like, what you commit to.

How does pricing actually work?

Vendor-funded. Discovery and the audit are free — no retainer, no upfront cost. When we place or renegotiate a vendor, the vendor pays our commission, and it goes on the contract in writing, so you see exactly what we make before you sign.

Where vendor-funded doesn't fit — pure compliance work, single-issue audits, interim CFO-style scopes — we'll quote a flat or capped engagement fee on the discovery call.

What does "vendor-funded" mean in real numbers?

Vendors build sales commissions into their pricing whether an advisor is involved or not — that money moves either way. When we place a vendor, the commission comes to us instead of their salesperson, and it's disclosed on the contract before you sign.

Translation: if we re-source your packaging and save you $500K/year, you keep the savings — the vendor pays us out of a contract you've already seen priced. If we don't find anything worth placing, nothing moves and you owe nothing. The disclosure removes our incentive to recommend work that doesn't pay back.

How long does an engagement take?

4–6 months total. Discovery 2–3 weeks, audit 3–4 weeks, implementation 8–16 weeks. Multi-state and three-pillar engagements run longer.

Monitoring is opt-in and ongoing — quarterly review cadence, capped fractional retainer, cancel anytime.

Do you take referral fees from vendors?

Yes — that's the model, and you see every dollar of it. There's a commission in every vendor deal whether it's visible or not; most firms hide theirs. Ours goes on the contract before you sign. We stay neutral because the bench is wide and the disclosure is total: recommendations are made on fit, across PEO, broker, ERP, POS, packaging, promo, and every other category — and you can check the math.

What if discovery doesn't find anything worth recovering?

We tell you that. Discovery costs nothing. If you're running clean, or the recoverable margin doesn't justify the engagement, we say so and walk away.

What happens after the engagement ends?

You keep the savings — all of them, for as long as they run. Our commission rides with the vendor contracts we placed, already disclosed and already priced in. Monitoring (optional) is a capped fractional retainer — not a share of new findings.

03Scope & Methodology

What we audit, how we audit it, what you get.

What does the HR audit actually cover?

Everything that touches your people-cost line:

  • PEO admin fee benchmarking — visible and the load buried inside medical premium
  • Health, dental, vision, voluntary benefits design
  • Workers' comp NAICS, mod rate analysis, broker / carrier benchmarking
  • Multi-state payroll vendor consolidation
  • Wage-and-hour compliance: classification, OT, meal breaks, sick leave
  • Tipped labor and FLSA compliance for hospitality and service-led brands
  • HRIS / ATS / time-and-attendance / scheduling stack rationalization
  • Background check and pre-hire vendor review
  • 401(k) plan fiduciary audit where applicable
What does the IT audit cover?

The full operating tech stack:

  • ERP fit by company size and vertical (NetSuite, SAP, Acumatica, Microsoft Dynamics, Sage, Brightpearl)
  • E-commerce platform fit (Shopify, BigCommerce, Salesforce Commerce)
  • POS rationalization (Toast, Square, Lightspeed, Aloha, Clover, NCR)
  • 3PL / WMS fit and integration health
  • Customer data platform review (Klaviyo, Attentive, Iterable, Tealium)
  • Loyalty / retention / subscription stack
  • SaaS inventory, license utilization, contract benchmarking
  • Multi-state / multi-tenant consolidation
  • Retired tenant cleanup — the bills still running for systems no one uses
What does the Supply Chain audit cover?

Four category tracks plus the cross-category playbook:

Packaging: primary (bottle, can, jar, pouch), closures and dispensers, label and print, secondary (carton, tray), tertiary (master, pallet). Factory-direct vs. agency markup analysis. MOQ, lead time, freight, duty.

Promo & sampling: premium and gift programs, sampling kits, branded merch, VIP gifting, custom collateral, promo agency benchmarking, group-buy and consolidated runs.

Apparel: staff uniforms, retail apparel, branded merch, decoration (embroidery, screen, sublimation), inventory program design, on-demand vs. bulk, domestic vs. import.

Displays & POP: retail floor and counter displays, permanent vs. temporary POP, trade-show booths, end-cap programs, custom fixture sourcing.

Across all four: factory-direct vs. agency markup mapping, freight and landed-cost analysis, MOQ negotiation, vendor consolidation strategy.

How do the three pillars work together?

HR, IT, and Supply Chain share an operating substrate. Most consultants pick a pillar; we built the practice on the seams between them — because that's where the leakage actually compounds:

  • HR ↔ IT: badge admin lives in HR, access control lives in IT. Time-and-attendance is IT, classification (which decides wage rules) is HR. PEO is HR, HRIS integration is IT.
  • IT ↔ SC: ERP cost centers, WMS-to-3PL integration, vendor master data, PO workflow, inventory accuracy.
  • HR ↔ SC: warehouse and fulfillment classification — pickers, packers, drivers — wage rules, comp NAICS, scheduling.
  • All three: the operating model itself. The playbook stitches them together.
What does a typical "finding document" look like?

A consolidated read of every recoverable dollar, organized by pillar (HR / IT / SC + the seams), prioritized by ROI and complexity. Each finding ties to a method, quantification, and recommended path. We co-present to leadership; you decide what to action.

It's typically 20–40 pages, not 200. We optimize for usable, not impressive.

Do you actually run the work, or just hand us a plan?

We run it. The value isn't in the plan — it's in the execution. We RFP vendors, sit on migration calls, draft policy rewrites, walk the warehouse. Done = savings tied back to PO and contract.

04The Playbook

The buy-side IP behind the practice: what's in it, where it came from, why it works.

Where does the playbook actually come from?

Years on the buying side — signing PEO contracts, picking ERPs, approving packaging, choosing display vendors across CPG, beverage, hospitality, lifestyle, and cannabis. Built from receipts we paid wrong, then paid right.

What's actually in the playbook?

Six core IP assets, applied across every engagement:

  • Vendor benchmarking against actual paid prices. Not list. Not "RFP industry average." The price the right operator paid last quarter for the same SKU, service, or headcount tier.
  • Factory-direct vs. agency markup map. Across packaging, promo, apparel, displays: who's actually making it, what the agency markup is, and when the agency genuinely earns it.
  • PEO & broker compensation transparency. The full P&L of your people-cost relationship — visible admin fee, hidden load inside medical, broker comp from the carrier.
  • SaaS & ERP utilization scoring. Which licenses are seats nobody uses. Which features you bought and never deployed. Which retired tenants are still billing.
  • Multi-state classification and comp NAICS. Where state wage law, federal exemption, comp coding, and tipped-labor compliance disagree.
  • Freight, duty, and landed-cost reality. What an FOB price actually costs you delivered. Where consolidation saves and where it doesn't.
What's "factory direct" actually mean for packaging or displays?

Sourcing from the factory making the SKU instead of through an agency. Direct relationships across packaging, promo, apparel, and displays.

Sometimes the agency genuinely earns its markup — design, project management, complex multi-vendor coordination, on-press supervision. Often it doesn't. The playbook tells you which is which.

Are there industries where the playbook doesn't transfer?

Built for consumer-facing brands — CPG, beverage, hospitality, lifestyle, cannabis — with multi-state operations or scaling toward them. Transfers cleanly because the buy side, people stack, and tech stack share an operating shape.

It doesn't transfer as cleanly to pure B2B / enterprise software, regulated financial services, or industrial manufacturing. We'll tell you on the discovery call if your operating model is outside our wheelhouse.

Can the playbook find quick wins, or is it always a full rebuild?

Both. Most engagements surface 2–4 quick wins in the first six weeks — a benchmarking gap, a WC misclassification, a retired SaaS tenant still billing. Often 10–20% of total engagement value early.

The deeper work — ERP migrations, PEO swaps, factory-direct sourcing programs — takes longer to land but compounds over the term.

How do you stay current with vendor pricing and category dynamics?

The playbook is living. Every engagement updates it — new benchmarks, tariffs, factory relationships, category dynamics. The data refresh happens organically.

Where we've got specific gaps, we say so. Some categories (electronics, technical components) we don't have deep enough buy-side history to claim coverage on. Most of what consumer brands actually spend on, we do.

05Fit & Logistics

Sizing, geography, NDAs, references.

How big does an operator need to be?

The model works best at ~$5M+ revenue, where vendor spend is large enough for placements to fund the work. Below that, we recommend a flat-fee scoped engagement or refer you to someone more appropriate.

What if we already work with consultants in HR, IT, or procurement?

That's the default. We coordinate with your CPA, counsel, brokers, and existing consultants. We're not replacing anyone — we're pulling the threads together and giving the operator a single point of accountability.

Do you handle interim CFO, fractional COO, or full ops takeover?

No. We're advisory. We don't sign as officer, run payroll, approve invoices, or negotiate on behalf of the entity. Where those needs arise, we coordinate with your team or refer.

Will you sign an NDA before discovery?

Yes. Mutual NDAs before any discovery work. Reference engagements shared only with explicit operator consent — the case studies here are anonymized composites.

Can you provide references from prior engagements?

Yes, on request and after the discovery call. We don't post a logo wall because most of our operator clients prefer not to publicize the engagement. Reference calls are standard once we're in serious discussion.

What if we already started something and want a second opinion?

That's a good place to start. A lot of our work begins as a second opinion on a vendor selection, a PEO migration, an ERP RFP, or a packaging RFP. We'll review what's on the table and tell you whether to proceed, renegotiate, or walk away.

How do we get started?

Book a 20-minute discovery call. We'll ask questions about your operating footprint, surface the obvious places to dig, and tell you whether a full discovery is worth the time. If it is, we propose scope. If it isn't, we say so.

Book the call here.

06By Category

The specific questions, silo by silo — the detail we keep off the sales pages on purpose.

HR · What does an HR audit actually cover?

PEO and benefits benchmarking, workers' comp — NAICS codes and the experience mod — multi-state classification, tipped-labor compliance, and HRIS rationalization. We work from a payroll summary and your invoices; most audits run 3–4 weeks without touching your team's day-to-day.

HR · Can you benchmark our PEO without disrupting payroll?

Yes. The benchmark runs off invoices and a census — nothing changes until you approve it. If a move makes sense, it's timed to your renewal so payroll never hiccups.

HR · Is UnifyWell a replacement for our benefits?

No — it's a complement, or a standalone where nothing's in place. ACA-compliant MEC coverage, $0 virtual care for your team, and payroll-tax savings that typically net ~$682 per employee per year. It's one of several benefits options on our bench — featured because the math wins.

IT · What does the IT audit cover?

The whole operating stack: ERP, e-commerce, POS, telecom, cloud, security, and the SaaS license list nobody reads. We map what you have, flag what's redundant or still billing after retirement, and price the keepers against market.

IT · Do we have to rip and replace our stack?

Almost never. Consolidation and renegotiation come first; we rebuild the integrations that matter and only recommend replacement when the math demands it — and you see that math before anything moves.

IT · How do you get better telecom and cloud pricing than we can?

Volume visibility. Our bench spans the major carriers and providers — enterprise to independent — and they compete for the work knowing every commission is disclosed on the contract.

SC · What does factory-direct actually save?

Agency markups on packaging, merch, and displays typically run 30–60% over factory-direct. We hold the factory relationships; you keep the difference. Where an agency genuinely earns its margin, we'll say so.

SC · What's in a freight & importing review?

Parcel and LTL audit, carrier contract re-bids, customs and HTS classification, duty and landed-cost engineering, and 3PL placement. It's the one supply chain category that pays back monthly, not once.

SC · We're small — do MOQs price us out?

No. The bench runs enterprise to independent, and group buys and consolidated runs get smaller brands factory-direct economics.

AI · What's your honest take on AI tools?

Human-first and right-sized. No GPT wrappers, no platform rebuilds — automation aimed at the admin work that steals hours, so your team does more of the work that matters. If it doesn't pay back, we don't propose it.

AI · Where does AI actually pay back first?

The boring places: workflow automation, system-to-system glue, and operating visibility. We start where the hours are bleeding, not where the demo looks best.

Still have questions?

The assessment is the answer.

Twenty minutes, no pitch. We'll tell you what we'd look at first, and whether there's anything worth chasing.

Get an Assessment